A Federal High Court judgment delivered by Justice Peter Lifu in Abuja has thrown the African Democratic Congress (ADC) into a fresh leadership crisis, placing former Vice President Atiku Abubakar’s ambition to contest the January 16, 2027 presidential election under serious legal uncertainty.
The judgment, delivered on November 5, 2026, followed a suit filed by Nafiu Bala Gombe, a former Deputy National Chairman of the ADC, against the party and other defendants.
The case centred on the emergence of former Senate President David Mark as the party’s National Chairman and former Osun State Governor Rauf Aregbesola as National Secretary.
Gombe had approached the court, arguing that following the resignation of the former National Chairman, Ralph Nwosu, the party’s constitution required leadership responsibilities to devolve to him.
He challenged the decision of the party’s National Executive Committee at its July 27, 2025 meeting to establish a caretaker leadership structure headed by Mark and Aregbesola, insisting that the process did not comply with the party’s constitution.
In his ruling, Justice Lifu upheld Gombe’s position and declared the emergence of Mark as National Chairman and Aregbesola as National Secretary unlawful.
The judge also questioned the authenticity of a purported resignation letter attributed to Gombe, stating that the signatures on the document differed from those contained in his sworn statements.
Consequently, the court declared all actions and decisions taken by the David Mark-led National Working Committee from July 27, 2025, null and void.
The court further directed the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) not to recognise the Mark-led leadership.
Justice Lifu relied on Section 82(3) of the Electoral Act 2022, which requires political parties to conduct democratic elections when choosing their officers. He maintained that decisions reached through party resolutions or administrative recognition by INEC could not replace the statutory requirement.
How The Judgment Affects Atiku Abubakar
Although Atiku Abubakar was not a party to the lawsuit, the judgment has raised serious questions about the validity of the process through which he emerged as the ADC presidential candidate for the 2027 general election.
Atiku’s lawyers have maintained that his name was not expressly mentioned in the operative orders contained in the Certified True Copy of the judgment released on November 11.
However, the argument surrounding his candidacy stems from the fact that the ADC leadership structure responsible for conducting the presidential primary has now been declared unlawful.
This has created uncertainty over whether the primary election that produced Atiku as the party’s presidential candidate can remain valid.
The ADC has rejected suggestions that the judgment automatically invalidates Atiku’s candidacy.
The party’s lawyer, Kalu Kalu, a Senior Advocate of Nigeria, argued during a television interview that no part of Justice Lifu’s ruling specifically nullified Atiku’s presidential ticket or the candidacies of other ADC members.
He insisted that the judgment was strictly concerned with the party’s leadership dispute and should not be interpreted as an order cancelling the presidential candidate’s nomination.
The disagreement is expected to be addressed by the Court of Appeal, where the ADC is challenging the ruling.
The party filed its notice of appeal on November 6, alongside an application seeking a stay of execution. It has also urged INEC not to take any action pending the determination of the appeal.
INEC Maintains Cautious Position
The electoral commission has also found itself at the centre of the controversy.
INEC National Commissioner, Mohammed Haruna, reportedly stated that the commission would wait until it received and examined the Certified True Copy of the judgment before deciding on its next line of action.
However, the five-day delay before the certified judgment became available generated complaints among ADC members and candidates.
Some party supporters protested at the Federal High Court in Abuja and petitioned the Chief Judge, Justice John Tsoho, over the handling and release of the judgment.
Conflicting Court Judgments Deepen ADC Leadership Crisis
The situation has become more complicated because the ADC claims that another Federal High Court judgment had previously recognised the David Mark-led leadership structure.
According to the party, an earlier ruling delivered by Justice Musa Liman affirmed the legitimacy of the leadership arrangement, which it said it relied upon in conducting its affairs.
The development has therefore raised questions about two conflicting judgments delivered by courts of coordinate jurisdiction over the same political party leadership dispute.
The legal position is that neither the ADC nor INEC can simply choose which judgment to recognise without considering the appropriate judicial process.
The Court of Appeal and, if necessary, the Supreme Court are expected to provide the final legal resolution.
Political observers have noted that leadership disputes and legal battles have repeatedly affected the electoral fortunes of Nigerian political parties, sometimes determining which candidates eventually appear on the ballot.
APC Rejects Allegations of Political Interference
The judgment has also generated political reactions, particularly regarding its possible implications for President Bola Tinubu and the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC).
For the APC, the development could weaken the opposition ahead of the 2027 presidential election, especially if Atiku is ultimately prevented from contesting on the ADC platform.
Atiku, who has contested the Nigerian presidency several times, is regarded as one of the most experienced opposition politicians and a major figure behind the coalition that adopted the ADC as its political platform.
His possible exclusion could therefore affect the strength and unity of the opposition coalition.
The ADC Presidential Campaign Council, through its spokesman, Kola Ologbondiyan, has accused the ruling APC of working towards what it described as a political coronation rather than a competitive election.
The campaign organisation alleged that there were efforts to ensure that no strong opposition candidate would be available to challenge Tinubu in 2027.
However, the APC has rejected the allegations, insisting that the crisis is an internal problem created by the ADC’s failure to comply with its constitution and the provisions of the Electoral Act.
The ruling party maintains that it should not be blamed for a dispute initiated by a member of the opposition party.
Concerns Over Democracy and Voters’ Rights
Beyond the political implications for Atiku and Tinubu, the judgment has reopened discussions about the relationship between judicial decisions, internal party democracy and the right of Nigerians to choose their preferred candidates.
Supporters of the ruling argue that political parties must obey the law and demonstrate internal democracy before seeking public support.
They maintain that a party that fails to conduct its own leadership elections in accordance with the law cannot reasonably claim to uphold democratic principles.
However, critics have expressed concern about the timing and possible consequences of the judgment, particularly because of its potential impact on ADC candidates contesting various positions.
They argue that disqualifying an opposition party’s candidates close to an election could affect millions of voters who have already identified with the party.
Atiku’s running mate, Rotimi Amaechi, has also warned that the situation could cause serious instability if not properly managed.
Nevertheless, the argument has been countered by those who insist that compliance with electoral laws must take precedence over political interests.
The article also recalled previous Supreme Court decisions involving the APC in Rivers and Zamfara states during the 2019 general elections.
In Zamfara, despite the APC winning the governorship, senatorial, House of Representatives and State Assembly elections, the Supreme Court ruled that the party had no valid candidates because it failed to conduct its primaries in accordance with the law.
Consequently, the court awarded the affected positions to candidates of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), which had come second in the elections.
The precedent is being cited to demonstrate that electoral victories and popular support cannot automatically override compliance with legal requirements.
Three Possible Outcomes for Atiku Ahead of 2027
The legal uncertainty surrounding Atiku’s candidacy has left him with three possible scenarios.
The first is a favourable ruling at the Court of Appeal. If the appellate court overturns Justice Lifu’s judgment or grants the requested stay of execution, Atiku could retain his ADC presidential ticket and continue his campaign for the 2027 election.
This is reportedly the outcome the ADC and its presidential candidate are hoping for.
The second possibility is that the Court of Appeal upholds the judgment. Such a decision could seriously threaten Atiku’s chances of contesting under the ADC platform.
Although he could theoretically seek another political platform, the tight INEC election timetable could make joining another party and conducting a fresh presidential primary extremely difficult.
The third possibility is a political settlement between the parties involved in the leadership dispute.
This could involve an agreement with Nafiu Bala Gombe, his withdrawal from the legal battle or the organisation of a fresh party convention under appropriate judicial supervision.
However, the possibility of such a settlement remains uncertain.
A Major Test for Nigeria’s Democracy
The unfolding ADC crisis represents a significant test for Nigeria’s political system as the country approaches the 2027 general election.
While the courts have a responsibility to ensure that political parties comply with electoral laws, judicial decisions delivered close to elections can also have far-reaching consequences for candidates, political parties and voters.
For Atiku Abubakar, the appeal represents one of the most consequential legal battles of his political career, with the outcome potentially determining whether he remains in the race for the presidency.
For President Tinubu and the APC, the possible absence of a major opposition figure and a strong opposition platform could create an additional political controversy surrounding the credibility and competitiveness of the 2027 election.
Ultimately, the ADC leadership dispute raises two important questions: whether political parties can uphold democracy without respecting their own constitutions and whether Nigeria can guarantee a genuinely competitive election when major opposition candidates face legal uncertainty.
As the appeal progresses, the political future of Atiku, the ADC and the wider opposition coalition remains uncertain.
READ ALSO:
- Obi to publish 10-day “Record of Service” on Anambra tenure after Tinubu’s erosion jibe
- Meta Expands AI Age Detection Globally to Catch Teens Lying About Their Age
- Pyrates Raise Diabetes Awareness, Advocate Early Detection at OGBC 90.5 FM Radio Sensitisation
- ZENITH BANK USHERS IN YULETIDE SEASON WITH DAZZLING CHRISTMAS LIGHT-UP, MARKS 20 YEARS OF FESTIVE TRADITION
- Obi Condemns Attack On Kwankwaso’s Convoy In Kano, Demands Arrests


